How to create trust in your company through social proof

There has been a lot of buzz about the importance of social proof in the success or failure of business today. As defined by Graham Charlton at EConsultancy, a community of digital marketing and eCommerce professionals, “Social proof is the phenomen[on] where people tend to believe that the decision and actions of others reflect the correct behaviour in a given situation.” As it applies to business, social proof is the consumer’s validation or condemnation of your products or brand, created through social sharing, commenting, and other digital engagement.

The rapid pivot between trust and disgust in the social proof equilibrium creates significant challenges for today’s businesses, because word-of-mouth marketing, customer reviews, and other social media engagement are so immediately and widely disseminated. The speed and viral network of positive and negative social proof makes it necessary for companies to constantly monitor and engage with customers on social media, provide social customer service, and implement new social proof techniques.

To assist in these regards, “specialists” and supporting technology have been launched related to customer review, online reputation, and social media management. Among the social review management companies are: GetFiveStars, CustomerLobby, Local ViewPoints, and ReviewTrackers; online reputation management companies such as, Reputation911,, and ReputationMarketingArmy; and social media monitoring tools and services like HootSuite and Trackur.

Some companies, like Charter Communications, have gone backward in their efforts to manage social proof, as evidenced by the elimination of their social media customer service team, according to the Consumerist. I had the pleasure of reporting on the good work that this team had been doing in an earlier article at the Web Chef’s Café, only to now experience its demise when I was seeking some assistance with remotely accessing my Charter Communications email. Given the direction that social business is going, forcing consumers to interact with the company primarily through “older” channels like phone or in person seems to be a poor business decision, albeit an effective short-term financial decision.

Social proof is generated by social following — likes and sharing of content through channels like Pinterest, Twitter, Facebook, LinkedIn, Google+, and other social media sites. As such, it is important that your social media and content strategy incorporate not only social icon links for individuals to follow your social sites, but also the social sharing tools (Pin It, Like, Tweet, Share, G+, etc.) to allow and encourage easy sharing of content to social media sites. The metrics related to sharing (the number of Pins, Likes, Tweets, and Shares, etc.) should be revealed as part of the social validation on your site.

Social proof is also being generated by product and service reviews at review sites like TripAdvisor, Yelp, UrbanSpoon, OpenTable, BazzaarVoice, and Angie’s List. Monitoring these review sites is increasingly important to your company, not only to stay apprised of consumer feedback and competitors’ positioning, but also to directly respond to customer sentiment, both positive and negative. In deciding how, when, and to whom to respond, evaluate the veracity and content of the review, the social currency of the reviewer, and whether it is an existing customer — after all, there are an awful lot of comment trolls out there.

One thing to avoid as part of your social proof marketing is the use of paid third parties to create positive reviews about your products or negative reviews of competitors. Research done at the Harvard Business School estimates that 25% of Yelp reviews are fraudulent reviews, often created to shine a favorable light on the business. Among the companies that have been hit with allegations of fake reviews is Samsung, which was recently accused of posting anonymous positive reviews about its products and negative reviews about a competitor’s products, according to Marketing Pilgrim.

Social proof is also being generated at many commerce and content sites through the reviews and comments enabled on those sites. If you allow outside reviews and comments on your site, it is important that you moderate this user-generated content to ensure it is accurate, non-prejudicial, and useful to site visitors.

Data on social reviews provided by PeopleClaim suggests that 75% of reviews are positive and that 82% of consumers find them valuable or extremely valuable.

Business actions and market reactions are also generating positive and negative social proof, as can be seen by the recent social media blowup over Barilla Pasta CEO Guido Barilla’s comments during an Italian radio show interview, where he said:

I would never do an advert with a homosexual family.

If they like our pasta and our message they will eat it; if they don’t like it then they will not eat it, and they will eat another brand.

The CEO’s comments led to a barrage of consumer boycott demands, creative social media protests (see below), and competitive social media responses from other pasta purveyors, including from Bertolli and Buitoni.

The uproar quickly led Guido Barilla to apologize and more recently to establish a diversity initiative that includes creating a diversity and inclusion board, appointing a chief diversity officer, and participating in the Human Rights Coalition (HRC) Corporate Equality Index, according to Buzzfeed. His initial apology can be seen below:



Some other ideas worth considering for your social proof marketing include:

  1. Third-party certifications by organizations like BizRate or Better Business Bureau.
  2. Letting visitors know how many others have purchased or viewed a product or service, much like eBay does in letting bidders know how many others have a particular product on their watch list.
  3. Providing Google maps showing the locations of comments, purchasers, or other social metrics.
  4. Encouraging votes for the best design or product, a la Threadless or Modcloth.

Beyond figuring out social proof techniques, it is important to recognize and work with diverse sources of social proof. As noted by Aileen Lee in her TechCrunch article “Social Proof Is the New Marketing,” these sources include:

  1. Expert social proof — testimonials, reviews from subject matter experts, whitepapers, webinars, and case studies.
  2. Celebrity social proof — testimonials, reviews, and other paid and unpaid media using celebrities to validate social proof of the product, service, or idea.
  3. User social proof — testimonials, customer reviews, and community bulletin board interaction from actual users.
  4. Wisdom-of-the-crowd social proof — validation through numbers of followers, subscribers, or other metrics.
  5. Wisdom-of-your-friends social proof — validation through the sharing of content with friends.

The key to social proof marketing is to encourage, monitor, and track social interactions with the goal of engaging with your customers over time through enhanced insights and loyalty.

For additional insights and tips on social and digital marketing strategy and tactics, add me to your circles at my Google+ page, follow me on Twitter @theWebChef, or follow my boards on Pinterest.

Click here to sign up for the free IB ezine – your twice-weekly resource for local business news, analysis, voices, and the names you need to know. If you are not already a subscriber to In Business magazine, be sure to sign up for our monthly print edition here.