Bookmark and Share Email this page Email Print this page Print Pin It
Feed Feed

Feb 9, 201509:56 AMMad @ Mgmt

with Walter Simson

What ‘Undercover Boss’ gets wrong

(page 1 of 2)

Reality TV and business don’t seem to be a good fit. The staged nature of the interactions — I am thinking of CNBC’s The Profit — is no more appealing than when non-business contestants are naked and on a beach.

There are exceptions. A great show that touches on business is Mike Rowe’s Dirty Jobs, which is now in syndication. Drain an alligator pond? Clean out a sewer? Chip out a stopped-up cement mixer? Mike shows both how it’s done and how hard — and ultimately, how skilled — the work really is. And the fascination with these unseen worlds is lightened by Mike’s comedic gifts, while the show also honors the workers who do society’s worst work. (And Mike, I’m pretty sure, is no low-class guy — the show once showed him breaking into a brief, baritone operatic aria while stuck in a smelly but acoustically interesting oil tank.)

But in the annals of reality TV series, few have been as wrongheaded as CBS’s Undercover Boss. In the show, a company CEO puts on theatrical makeup and, posing as a new employee, joins frontline troops accompanied by a camera crew. After five-plus seasons, one suspects that everyone knows that the goofball in the bad hippie haircut is really the boss, but they have reasons to keep up the charade, as we will see.

So the new employee has to learn regular workers’ skills. But rather than showing how difficult the work is, the way Mike Rowe does, the show demeans the work by making the boss into a spectacular screw-up. He can’t flip a pizza, or key a cash register, or answer inquiries from retail customers. Sometimes it appears he doesn’t even try.

A recent episode featured a boss as an untrained warehouse worker getting on a forklift and operating it in an unsafe manner — going so far as to crash it into warehouse racking. The camera catches the three-story-high racks wavering ominously above the workers. This takes the CEO silliness to a new low — pretending as if any responsible company would let an untrained worker put his or others’ life and limb at risk.

When the undercover boss is not screwing up, he is idly gossiping, hearing about low company morale and the difficult lives of his minimum-wage co-workers. They, meanwhile, make sure the new guy knows that they themselves perform acts of heroism on behalf of the corporation.

Meanwhile, the so-called joke of the show is hearing the probably complicit co-workers whispering at how incompetent — wink, wink — the new guy is.

Then comes the reveal. The screw-up is really your boss! And he has been so touched by the dedication and personal travails of his camera-ready-and-wired-for-sound co-workers that he is going to give them lots of money to end their sorrows.

Thirty thousand to pay off college loans! Ten thousand for a wheelchair ramp for Grandma! Forty thousand for a down payment on a new house!

Then tears, hugs, and the co-workers declaiming their absolute surprise at their good fortune (more winks) and the goodness of the undercover boss.

Here is where the thoughtful watcher would wonder, “What about the low-wage worker next to these fortunate few?” The show not only lamely makes light of their work, it rewards a fortunate few while ignoring the school loans, car troubles, and grandmas of everyone else. Logically, it doesn’t work.


Old to new | New to old
Feb 11, 2015 06:41 am
 Posted by  Anonymous

Guess you haven't watched all the shows, Walter. I see leaders who take the time to really understand what is happening out in the trenches and do make long-term changes. And indeed, the boss made changes in a humans life--giving them the gift of an education and helping them grow as defined by servant leadership. Maybe we watched different episodes.

Feb 11, 2015 08:04 am
 Posted by  Anonymous

Thank you for your comment and especially its respectful tone.

I guess I don't feel servant leadership is, by definition, episodic. Reality TV, by definition, is. Happy you enjoy the show.--Walter

Feb 11, 2015 08:12 am
 Posted by  Anonymous

I agree with some of these points ... yeah, if this is such a great company, why are so many of your employees low wage earners? The concept of the CEO getting in the trenches and being aware of the customer experience is very important, though. I've always said I'd never ask anyone to do anything I wouldn't do myself. The CEO should have a basic knowledge of what his workers do and then figure out how to make it better. One of the first episodes they did (before workers got wise to it) was on the Great Wolf Resorts. The CEO discovered the registration system was ridiculously long and convoluted and needed to be changed. The message is important. The made-for-tv-drama part of it, not so much.

Add your comment:
Bookmark and Share Email this page Email Print this page Print Pin It
Feed Feed
Edit Module Edit Module